Natural Menopause Supplements: The Magnesium Paradox (Part 2)
In Part 1 of this series, we explored why women turn to natural solutions - and why that journey is both completely understandable and potentially problematic. Now let's explore what might be the most recommended (and misunderstood) supplement in menopause: magnesium.
Magnesium is one of the most recommended supplements for menopause and is a perfect example of how everyone can be simultaneously right and wrong about supplements. That bottle of magnesium your friend swears fixed her sleep issues? It might be exactly what you need - or it might keep you up at night because you are visiting the bathroom with explosive diarrhea.
The Magnesium Story: Not As Simple As "Just Take a different kind" When Magnesium Became Menopause's Rock Star (Literally, It's a Rock)
Let's talk about magnesium - if there was a popularity contest for menopause supplements, magnesium would win by a landslide.
Why Everyone's Obsessed With Magnesium After watching thousands of women navigate natural solutions, let's talk about the supplement that's become the unofficial queen of menopause relief. If there was a popularity contest for menopause supplements, magnesium would win by a landslide.
Pop into any menopause forum and you'll find it prescribed for everything from sleepless nights to cranky muscles to heart palpitations. The fascinating thing is – the hype isn't entirely misplaced. Your body uses this mighty mineral in over 300 enzymatic processes. From muscle function to nervous system regulation, proper sleep to mood stability – magnesium plays a crucial role in how your body navigates menopause.
Nutrient Levels & Mineral Content: How Our Food Supply Has Changed
A Story about Our Food Supply
But here's where things get interesting (and a bit depressing). When people say, "Our ancestors got enough magnesium from food," they're both right and wrong. Yes, humans evolved getting sufficient magnesium from their food supply. But – and this is crucial – that food supply looked nothing like what's on your plate today, even if you're shopping at the fancy organic market.
Modern agricultural practices have fundamentally depleted our soil. A carrot today contains significantly less magnesium than a carrot from 1950.
This goes beyond the organic versus conventional farming conversation – it reflects broader changes in how we grow and distribute food. While modern farming and distribution systems have made fresh produce available year-round, they've also brought new challenges. Even high-quality organic produce today often contains different nutrient levels than its counterparts from previous generations.
The Ayurvedic View: Prāna, Modern Food, and Mineral Balance
From an Ayurvedic perspective, there's another fascinating layer to consider: prana, or the vital life force energy in our food. Think about the journey most produce takes to reach our plates – often traveling across countries or continents.
This means fruits and vegetables need to be harvested early, before they've developed their full nutrient profile through natural ripening. And during those long journeys from farm to table, food gradually loses its prana.
In Ayurveda, we understand that optimal nourishment comes not just from proteins, carbohydrates, minerals and vitamins, but also from this vital energy that makes food truly satisfying and nourishing for both body and mind.
Understanding these challenges with our modern food supply, many women turn to supplements to bridge the nutritional gap.
It's a logical step – if we can't get enough magnesium from food, surely supplementation is the answer? But after years of working in both natural products retail and Ayurvedic practice, I've learned it's not quite that straightforward.
Here's what you need to know:
Choosing Magnesium Forms: When Your Friend's Solution Isn't Yours
Form Matters:
Let's start with a simple truth – magnesium is a mineral, literally derived from the earth. When we're talking about supplements, we're essentially talking about different ways of making rock digestible. This might sound strange, but it helps explain why form is so crucial for absorption.
The common magnesium oxide supplements you'll find on most shelves have an absorption rate of only about 4%. The remaining 96% passes through your digestive system, often causing uncomfortable digestive issues. This leads many people to purchase additional supplements to manage these unwanted effects.
Magnesium citrate pairs the mineral with citric acid, making it more easily recognized by your body. While it absorbs better than oxide, its strong osmotic effect means it can still trigger digestive elimination – which explains why it's often found in supplements meant for occasional constipation.
Magnesium glycinate, where the mineral is bound to the amino acid glycine, tends to be gentler on digestion and can support both sleep and nerve function. It's often recommended for those with sensitive digestive systems.
Magnesium malate combines magnesium with malic acid, which your cells naturally produce. This form is particularly interesting for energy production and muscle function, though it's typically more expensive than other options.
The supplement industry continues to develop new magnesium formulations, often combining them with other nutrients in search of better absorption and fewer side effects. You'll find magnesium paired with vitamin D (which is actually a hormone, not a vitamin), zinc, and various other minerals. While some of these combinations make sense from a biological perspective, others seem driven more by marketing than science. The challenge isn't just finding the "right" form – it's understanding how these nutrients work together in your unique body.
Before reaching for supplements, let's look at where magnesium naturally occurs in our food.
Dark leafy greens like spinach and Swiss chard offer substantial amounts, especially when cooked. Seeds and nuts are particularly rich sources – pumpkin seeds, sesame seeds, and almonds make excellent snacks or additions to meals.
Avocados not only provide magnesium but offer healthy fats that support its absorption. Even dark chocolate contains meaningful amounts (yes, really!).
While our modern food supply may have lower mineral content than in the past, incorporating these foods regularly can help support your magnesium needs.
Individual Differences:
Just as Ayurveda recognizes different doṣas, our bodies have different needs and absorption capabilities. What works for your best friend might turn your digestive system into a painful mess.
Signs and Signals: Is Your Magnesium Supplement Working?
The Body's Warning Signs: Here's something I've noticed repeatedly: your body speaks up when a supplement isn't right, But we've been conditioned to dismiss these signals because we believe anything natural must be safe and healthy.
Digestive changes, headaches, energy crashes – these are real responses from your body, not minor inconveniences to push through. When we operate under the belief that "natural equals safe," we might ignore clear signs that a supplement isn't working for us, or worse, is creating new problems.
A More Nuanced Approach:
After thirty years in this field, here's what I've learned about magnesium:
Testing Matters: Most magnesium tests are about as useful as a chocolate teapot because they measure blood levels, not cellular levels where magnesium actually does its work.
Food First: Yes, our soil is depleted, but focusing on magnesium-rich foods along with proper digestion (agni for the win!) often works better than supplements alone.
Absorption is Key: Ayurveda teaches us that it's not just what you take, but how well your body can use it. Factors like stress, digestive fire, and even the time of day can affect how well you absorb magnesium.
Making Magnesium Work: Questions to Guide Your Choices
Finding Your Balance Rather than asking "Should I take magnesium?" try asking:
How's my digestion really doing?
What form of magnesium might work best for my body type and symptoms?
What other factors might be affecting my mineral absorption?
Am I taking other supplements or medications that might be playing bouncer to my magnesium?
This brings us to perhaps the most fascinating adaptogenic root in the natural supplement world - ashwagandha.
If magnesium is the most recommended supplement for menopause symptoms, ashwagandha is the latest super herb recommended for everything including menopause.
As an Ayurvedic practitioner, every time I see ashwagandha added into every thing my brain breaks.
In our next piece, we'll explore why this effective ancient adaptogen isn't the miracle cure Instagram wants you to believe it is - and why it might still be exactly what you need.
Can't wait for Part 3? The complete series is available now on my Substack 'Art of Menopausing: Hidden in Plain Sight' Hello again! I've moved my writing and community space to Substack, where I can focus more on what matters most - connecting deeply with you and sharing meaningful insights about [Ayurveda/menopause/wellbeing/sanskrit/midlife matters], without the technical fuss of website management.
Over on Substack, we're building something special - a space where wisdom flows both ways and every subscription (free or paid) is part of an energy exchange that helps keep this work sustainable. You'll find new thoughtful perspectives, deeper discussions, and a community that gets it.
Care to join me in deeper conversations? Head over to Art of Menopausing Hidden in Plain Sight. Everything's free to read, and you can choose to support this work with a paid subscription if it resonates with you.
Peace
Chitra