Hey! Just so you know - I now write and share insights over on Substack (it's like a newsletter-meets-blog platform where we can actually talk to each other!). While this post lives here, you'll find all my new work and our growing community at https://artofmenopausing.substack.com.
This is part four in our series examining natural supplements and menopause. In part one, we explored why women turn to natural solutions. Part two investigated magnesium's complex role in menopause, while part three revealed why ashwagandha affects women so differently.
The complexity of individual herbs points to a larger truth: personalizing menopause supplements matters more than quantity. While the supplement industry promotes universal solutions, your body tells a more nuanced story. Let's examine why this personalization is crucial for supporting your body through menopause.
The Supplementation Paradox: Why More Isn't Better
I watched a woman at the coop methodically filling her basket: calcium for bones, magnesium for sleep, vitamin D for mood, ashwagandha for stress, black cohosh for hot flashes... By the time she reached the counter, she had twelve different supplements. "I'm determined to do menopause naturally," she declared. And there I stood, biting my tongue so hard I probably needed a supplement for it.
At what point does 'natural' supplementation become as artificial as the conventional treatments we're trying to avoid?"
Personalizing Menopause Supplements: A Holistic Approach
The irony runs deep. In our quest to avoid pharmaceutical medications, we've simply swapped one pill-for-every-symptom mindset for another. We've traded prescriptions for supplements while keeping the same reductionist thinking that got us here in the first place. It's like changing the actors but keeping the same problematic script.
Here's what I've learned watching thousands of women navigate their health:
Menopausal symptoms aren't your enemy. Every hot flash, every sleepless night, every mood swing is your body trying to tell you something important. When we rush to silence these messages with supplements, we miss the whole conversation.
It's like putting your fingers in your ears and humming while your best friend tries to tell you something crucial.
The Supplement Spiral
Consider this all-too-familiar scene from my practice:
A woman takes magnesium for sleep
The magnesium throws her digestion into chaos
She adds digestive enzymes
Those create acid reflux
She reaches for herbs to calm the reflux And down the rabbit hole we go...
How to Choose Menopause Supplements: An Ayurvedic Guide
"You're not what you eat – you're what you can digest, absorb, assimilate, and eliminate."
In Ayurveda, there's a fundamental truth: You're not what you take – you're what you can digest, absorb, assimilate, and eliminate. (Sorry, but that $75 bottle of supplements isn't doing much if it's just creating expensive pee.) This is where our supplement obsession breaks down:
Multiple supplements overwhelm digestive capacity (agni) at every level
Weakened digestion leads to poor absorption
Undigested supplements create toxic buildup (ama)
Poor assimilation means tissues aren't getting what they need
The body gets weaker trying to process and eliminate the excess
We add more supplements to fix problems caused by poor assimilation
And the cycle continues...
The Hidden Costs
The cost isn't just financial (though I've seen monthly supplement bills that would make a luxury car payment look reasonable). It's the mental load of complex schedules, the stress of endless research, the anxiety of never doing "enough," and most importantly – the burden on your body's intelligence.
The women who navigate menopause most gracefully often take fewer supplements, not more. Plot twist, right?"
Here's what fascinates me: The women who navigate menopause most gracefully often take fewer supplements, not more. They focus on:
Deep nourishment through food (yes, actual food!)
Supporting digestive strength
Addressing root causes through lifestyle
Using specific supplements strategically, not scattershot
Making Peace with Supplements: Developing Your Individual Strategy
"I feel like I'm doing everything right," my client sighed, sliding a three-page supplement diary across my desk during her initial Ayurvedic consultation. Each page meticulously documented what she took, when she took it, and what happened. Her frustration was palpable – and familiar.
Doing 'everything right' according to general advice often means doing everything wrong for your unique body.
Redefining "Natural" Healing Through Ayurveda
What if I told you that true natural healing has little to do with finding the perfect supplement combination? It's really about understanding three fundamental aspects of your body's intelligence:
1. Your Unique Blueprint
Your doṣha (fundamental constitution)
Your agni (digestive fire)
Your current āma (toxin) levels
2. Your Natural Rhythms
Your dinacharya (daily routines)
Your seasonal shifts
Your patterns of eating, sleeping, and movement
3. Your Body's Language
Symptoms are messages, not enemies
Breaking free from the "suppress and push through" cycle
Creating a sustainable way to listen to your body
Your Practical Path Forward
Before reaching for another supplement, try this for two weeks:
Symptom Mapping and Tracking
Create a list of your symptoms
Choose your primary focus symptom
Note patterns in other symptoms
Record when symptoms shift
Document triggers (food, activities, thoughts)
Map your daily rhythm patterns
Notice how your body responds to different inputs
Finding Support
Remember this: supplements are like scaffolding – temporary support structures, not permanent solutions. True healing emerges from understanding and working with your body's innate wisdom, especially when guided by Ayurvedic principles of harmony for your unique constitution.
The word "supplement" literally means "in addition to" - not instead of your body's natural healing capacity.
As you navigate your own supplement journey, remember that your body's resistance isn't a failure – it's valuable information about what you really need.
True healing emerges from understanding and working with your body's innate wisdom, guided by Ayurvedic principles of balance and your unique constitution.
Ready to explore an Ayurvedic approach to menopause?
Join me for a Chai & Chat - a warm 30-minute conversation to explore what your body is really telling you.
Hello again! I've moved my writing and community space to Substack, where I can focus more on what matters most - connecting deeply with you and sharing meaningful insights about [Ayurveda/menopause/wellbeing/sanskrit/midlife matters], without the technical fuss of website management.
Over on Substack, we're building something special - a space where wisdom flows both ways and every subscription (free or paid) is part of an energy exchange that helps keep this work sustainable. You'll find new thoughtful perspectives, deeper discussions, and a community that gets it.
Care to join me in deeper conversations? Head over to Art of Menopausing Hidden in Plain Sight. Everything's free to read, and you can choose to support this work with a paid subscription if it resonates with you.
Peace
Chitra